BOTTLE CRUSH: THANKSGIVING EDITION

Turkey, stuffing, homemade cranberry sauce or cran in a can? You have enough on your plate, so let us pick the wine. And with Beaujolais Nouveau out on the third Thursday in November, it has to make the list.

Wine experts Elissa Feist, Toni Riggi, Hillary Zio + Miles Merton tell us what they’re pouring.


ELISSA FEIST — TROY WINE CO.
Red pick: Common Wealth Crush, Family Meal

“I featured six wines in my Thanksgiving wine class, but if I’m choosing two, it has to be Family Meal, a Virginian red blend, and this Romanian Aligoté.

American wine started in Virginia, built by hands rarely credited in history books. Today, James Beard Award-winning sommelier Lee Campbell’s diversity-focused incubator is opening the cellar doors to all. This field blend includes Merlot, Grüner Veltliner, and Petit Manseng and brings juicy red fruit, bright acidity, and easy-drinking charm. Plus, it pairs with just about everything on the Thanksgiving table!” — EF

[Ed. note: Common Wealth Crush Co. is a custom crush facility, winery incubator, and cooperative winemaking operation located in the historic Virginia Metalcrafters Building in Waynesboro, Virginia, within the Shenandoah Valley AVA. Production—lead by the award-winning, African American, woman winemaker, sommelier and all-round (s)hero, Lee Campbell—focuses on minimal-intervention, non-traditional blends, and high-acidity wines made with Shenandoah Valley fruit. All Common Wealth Crush label wines are unfined and unfiltered.]

White pick: Crama Delta Dunarii, La Sapata Aligoté

“Often overshadowed by Chardonnay in its native region of Burgundy, Aligoté has found a second home in Romania, where it has been grown for generations. This vibrant white offers crisp green apple, zesty citrus, white flowers, and a touch of salty minerality. Bright acidity and a refreshing finish make it an easy match for everything from oysters and roast poultry to the rich, buttery sides on your holiday table.” - EF

Elissa Feist is the wine buyer + educator of Troy Wine Co.., Clark House Hospitality, Troy, N.Y.
‍Sign up for the wine Troy Wine Club
here.


TONI RIGGI — Owner-Wine Director, Toni’s Wine Bar, Schenectady

Red pick: Zajc Cviček Slovenian Red Blend

“I am a big fan of the Cviček style wine out of the Dolenjska region of Slovenia. The one we carry is produced by the Zajc family who has been making wine since the second half of the 19th century. It is unique because it is a co-ferment of red and white grapes. It is light and refreshing with bright acidity and will not overpower any of the hearty Thanksgiving flavors. It also stays below 10% in ABV which is a nice touch for all day drinking.

White pick: Rosewood Estates "Neptune" Riesling, Ontario, CA

“My other recommendation is a Canadian Riesling produced by Rosewood Estates on the Niagara Peninsula in Ontario. It is called Neptune after the Roman god of the sea. The grapes are whole-cluster pressed and fermented in French oak. It has a nice salinity (hence the name) and is rich and spicy. Certainly on the drier side. I am also partial to this wine because it’s imported by a female-founded import company.”


HILLARY ZIO, Isola Wine Bar, Kinderhook

“My two favorite wines for Thanksgiving might surprise you, but I actually suggest a serious Cava and a winter rosé!

Why Cava? A well-made, traditionally fermented Cava like Avinyó Reserva Brut brings much more than just bubbles. Extended aging on the lees gives it savory, toasty, brioche-like complexity that feels right at home alongside roasted turkey, buttery mashed potatoes, stuffing, and gravy. Its bright acidity cuts through all that richness, while the bubbles refresh your palate between bites. It's festive, but it's also a genuinely brilliant food wine.

And why rosé in November? Because not all rosé is meant for a beach in July. A deeper, more structured rosé like Podere Le Ripi's Cappuccetto Rosa from Tuscany has the red-fruit character, savory undertones, and texture to stand up to an autumn table. Think roasted turkey skin, sausage stuffing, mushrooms, sweet potatoes, and cranberry sauce. It offers some of the satisfaction of a red wine without the tannins that can clash with Thanksgiving's sweeter dishes.

Also, Thanksgiving isn't one perfectly composed plate. It's ten different flavors competing for attention, and these are wines that can move effortlessly between them.

** Luckily both of these are included in my  November Wine Club shipment. When you sign up before 11/20, you'll get a $50 gift certificate to Isola Wine & Tapas! 

Read our full tastemaker interview with sommelier + author, Hillary Zio, here.
Sign up for the Isola Wine Club here.


MILES MERTON — Wine Director, Familiar Creature, Saratoga

“For the Thanksgiving table, I’d recommend an off-dry Chenin Blanc, Beaujolais, and a Bandol Rosé. I won’t get too specific… Just go to your local wine store, ask for the above, and have a time at the table!

From our What We’re Pouring list, we currently have Domaine du Jonchay, Les Pendrouilles, a 2023 Beaujolais, by the glass. This Gamay is juicy and bright, with raspberry, red currant, and a soft earthy spice on a light, gulpable frame. Domaine du Jonchay makes expressive Beaujolais that keeps the fruit fresh while showing the region’s easy charm.”

Read our tastemaker interview with Miles Merton here.

Previous
Previous

INDUSTRY TALK: How a New, Smaller Model Delivers Big On Hospitality at Sara’s Kitchen, Saratoga

Next
Next

SAUD KHAN—TIKTOK’S CHAIGUY—TALKS PAKISTANI POP UPS + REOPENING UPSTATE